What to text back when he says he usually doesn't do dating apps
He's signaling he's not a typical app user. Learn what he really means and how to reply without seeming too eager or dismissive.
When a guy says he doesn't usually do dating apps, he's often testing the waters or explaining why he might seem rusty at this. It's a half-apology wrapped in a statement about his preferences. He's either new to apps, tends to meet people in person, or is wondering if you're worth the effort even though he's stepping outside his normal pattern.
Your reply needs to show you took it seriously without over-explaining yourself or getting defensive. You want to move past the meta-commentary about dating apps and into actual conversation about him or making plans. Good replies either acknowledge what he said lightly and redirect, or ask a follow-up question that keeps things moving.
Get replies that sound like you
Screenshot the conversation in WingAI. It reads the vibe and gives you natural replies for this exact situation.
Try for freeHe's either testing you or setting expectations
When someone leads with 'I don't usually do this,' they're often managing how you perceive them. He might worry he'll come across as app-desperate or he's uncomfortable with the format. Sometimes it's a real statement about his dating history. Other times it's a conversational opener to see if you'll relate or if you're a hardcore app user who'll judge him.
Don't treat this as a problem to solve. He's not asking you to convince him that apps are good. He's telling you something about his comfort level or his typical dating behavior. Read it as context about how he approaches meeting people, not as a question requiring a detailed response.
Acknowledge without mirroring, then ask or suggest
A strong reply shows you heard him without getting stuck on the topic. You can briefly validate the statement, but only if it's true for you. Then pivot. Either ask him something that follows naturally from what he said, like how he actually does meet people or what brought him to try the app now. Or steer toward actual connection by commenting on something from his profile or suggesting a call.
The move is to treat it as a passing detail, not the centerpiece of your conversation. Spend one sentence on it maximum. Use the second sentence to show interest in him as a person or to move things forward. This tells him you're not hung up on app culture and you're focused on whether the two of you click.
Respond within a day or two, don't overthink the wait
Reply in your normal texting window. Waiting too long to respond to this kind of statement can make it feel heavy or like you're crafting something meaningful, which defeats the point of treating it lightly. Send it when you see it or within a normal texting timeframe for you.
If he doesn't respond after your reply, wait three to five days before sending another message. If you've sent two messages with no response, stop. This isn't a sign to keep trying. It often means he was app-browsing casually or testing the waters without real intent. Don't treat silence as rejection. Treat it as a person who wasn't actually ready or interested enough to follow through.
Why these replies fail
“Haha same, I barely use dating apps either honestly”
You're clearly on the app messaging him, so this reads as dishonest and makes him question what you just said.
“Oh word? So what made you join then?”
Puts him on the defensive immediately and sounds like you're challenging his credibility instead of just moving forward.
“That's cool. Yeah dating apps can be pretty weird lol”
You validate him but then stop the conversation entirely, leaving no clear path forward for either of you to continue.
Common mistakes
- Treating it like a confession and saying 'me neither' when you clearly do use the app
- Over-validating by saying 'that's cool' or 'totally get it' and then stopping
- Launching into why you DO use apps, which makes it about you instead of him
- Asking 'so why are you here then?' which sounds accusatory
- Ignoring it completely and changing the subject, which feels like you're avoiding his point
Questions people ask
- Does saying he doesn't usually do dating apps mean he's not serious?
- Not necessarily. Some people really do prefer meeting in person but are open to trying an app. Others are new to the city or going through a life change. What matters is his behavior after this statement. Does he ask questions? Make plans? Or does he ghost? That's what signals his actual investment.
- Should I ask why he joined the app if he doesn't usually use them?
- Only if it feels natural to the flow of your conversation. If he brought it up unprompted, he might appreciate not having to defend it further. You can ask casually later if you're already vibing. Right now, asking can feel like you're interrogating him about his presence on the platform.
- What if I actually don't use dating apps much either?
- Then you can say so briefly and move on. Keep it light. Don't make it the focus of your conversation. Use it as a small connection point and then redirect to learning about him or suggesting something concrete like a call or meeting up.
- Is this a red flag or just something people say?
- It's just something people say. Some mean it completely, some are being modest, some are testing you. A red flag would be if he says this and never engages further, or if he keeps bringing it up repeatedly as an excuse for poor communication.
What people say after using WingAI
“She went cold mid-week and I had no idea what to say. The reply I sent felt natural and she picked the chat back up.”
Marcus T.
“I overthink every text. Having three options and picking the one that sounds like me cut that spiral short.”
Sam R.
“I was skeptical at first. Then I tried it on a dry chat and the replies actually sounded like me, not a chatbot.”
Mazoonx
Get replies that sound like you
Screenshot the conversation in WingAI. It reads the vibe and gives you natural replies for this exact situation.
Try for free