What to say when he mentions another girl he's been talking to
How to reply when he brings up someone else on the dating app. Stay calm, read what he's really doing, and respond without drama.
When a guy volunteers that he's talking to someone else, he's testing the room. He might be looking for permission to keep juggling. He might feel guilty and want to clear the air. He might think it makes him look desirable. Or he's just being transparent because he's considering whether you're worth focusing on.
Your reply matters because it sets the terms. Do you care? Are you cool with it? Will you compete? Will you walk? A good reply doesn't pretend you don't mind when you do. It also doesn't spiral into drama. It acknowledges what he said, stays even emotionally, and makes him think about what he actually wants.
Get replies that sound like you
Screenshot the conversation in WingAI. It reads the vibe and gives you natural replies for this exact situation.
Try for freeRizz AI Screenshot the chat and get the next message for this person.
He's either testing you or cleaning his conscience
Guys bring up other girls for two main reasons. First, he's checking whether you'll get upset, cry, or just accept it. That tells him what kind of partner you'll be. Second, he feels a little guilty and wants credit for being honest instead of just disappearing on you while he figures things out.
Neither reason means he's made a choice yet. He's still in the decision phase. What matters is whether he's told you this because he wants your permission to keep dating around, or because he's leaning toward you and needed to clear the air first. His tone and timing tell you which one it is. If he volunteers it early and seems apologetic, he's probably testing the waters. If he brings it up after things have gotten warmer between you, he might actually be trying to be fair.
Show you heard him, set a boundary, and move on
Your reply needs to do two things at once. First, acknowledge what he said without making him feel like he needs to defend himself. Don't pretend you didn't hear it. Don't ignore it and change the subject. That reads as weak.
Second, make it clear you're not comfortable being one of several at this stage. Not as a rule about how dating should work. As a statement about what you need from him to keep going. Then actually let the conversation move. Don't relitigate it. Don't ask follow-up questions about her. Don't spiral. The point is to let him know you're selective about who gets your time, and now he knows the terms.
Wait for his next move and stick to it
After you reply, do not text him again first. He knows the situation now. If he's interested in you specifically, he'll either stop talking to her or he'll slow things down with you while he figures it out. Both of those are fine. If he keeps pushing forward with you without addressing what he said, that's a tell. He's hoping you'll forget he mentioned it.
Give him two to three days. If you don't hear from him, he's probably still deciding or he's lost interest because you didn't react the way he wanted. Either way, your job is done. Move on. Do not follow up asking what's happening. Do not soften your boundary. That just teaches him you didn't mean it.
Why these replies fail
“Oh that's cool, I'm talking to other people too lol. No pressure”
This signals you don't care about him and removes all stakes, which makes him feel less special and more likely to pursue the other girl instead.
“Wow okay. What's she like? How long have you been talking to her?”
You're asking him to compare you and feeding his ego by showing you're invested in the competition, which actually makes the other girl more interesting to him.
“I can't believe you'd tell me this. I thought you were different. I guess I'm done here.”
You're punishing him for being honest and making it about your feelings instead of actually deciding if this is what you want, which feels manipulative to him.
Common mistakes
- Getting angry or hurt and showing it right away, which makes you look threatened and him more powerful
- Saying you're totally cool with it when you're not, which signals you have low standards and kills his interest
- Turning it into a competition by asking about her, which shifts focus away from him choosing you
- Going silent and ghosting him, which avoids the conversation instead of handling it
- Over-explaining your feelings or asking lots of questions, which makes you seem insecure
Questions people ask
- Does him mentioning another girl mean he's not interested in me?
- Not necessarily. He might be interested in you and wanting to be fair by telling you he's still exploring options. Or he's testing whether you'll get upset. The fact he told you at all is actually a signal he thinks you might care. If he wasn't interested, he'd just quietly fade.
- Should I mention other guys I'm talking to as a power move?
- Only if it's true and only if it's relevant. If you invent competition to match his, he'll sense it and lose respect. If you're actually talking to other people, you can mention it naturally. But don't do it just to make him jealous. That's reactive and transparent.
- What if he says he wants to keep talking to both of us?
- That's him asking permission to have options while keeping you around. You get to say no. You can say you're looking for someone who's focused on you once things start getting real, and that time is now. Then let him decide. Do not negotiate down or seem flexible on this.
- How long should I wait before deciding he's not serious about me?
- If he brings up another girl and then keeps dating you the same way without changing course, give it a week or two. After that, his behavior shows you what he's doing. If nothing shifts and he's still divided, you have your answer. Stop waiting for him to choose and choose for yourself.
What people say after using WingAI
“I overthink every text. Having three options and picking the one that sounds like me cut that spiral short.”
Sam R.
“I was skeptical at first. Then I tried it on a dry chat and the replies actually sounded like me, not a chatbot.”
Mazoonx
“Didn't think it would be this good. The funny options actually get responses, which is wild.”
Nico_dang
Get replies that sound like you
Screenshot the conversation in WingAI. It reads the vibe and gives you natural replies for this exact situation.
Try for free