What to do when they say they're still on dating apps
Calm, direct replies for when someone says they're still on dating apps, plus how to read it, how long to wait, and when to stop following up.
When someone says they're still on other dating sites, they're usually telling you two things. They haven't closed the door on other options yet, and they would rather tell you than have you find out later. Both count as information. Treat it as an answer to a question you didn't ask out loud.
What a good reply does here is answer the question underneath, which is usually whether this changes anything for you and whether you're still in the running. It doesn't need to match their honesty with a confession, and it doesn't need to pretend the mention didn't land. A short, unbothered answer followed by one real question works better than a speech about your standards.
The conversation also has to keep moving toward something, usually a date or a clearer sense of where they stand. If the mention came up in the middle of a chat that was going well, let the chat carry on. If it came up as a reason to slow down, deal with that directly instead of hoping it passes.
Get replies that sound like you
Screenshot the conversation in WingAI. It reads the vibe and gives you natural replies for this exact situation.
Try for freeRizz AI Screenshot the chat and get the next message for this person.
Still swiping elsewhere means something specific
Start with the wording. "Still on there" and "haven't deleted yet" are different from "I'm mostly off them now," and all of them differ from a joke that trails into a question about you. Early on, the mention is usually housekeeping. People who have been burned before say it upfront so nobody feels misled later, and a calm reaction is often what they are checking for.
After a couple of dates the same sentence carries more weight. It can mean they are still comparing you with other options, or that they haven't decided what they want. Watch what happens when you ask about plans. Someone keeping options open tends to stay vague, while someone who has moved on gives you a rough timeframe without being pushed.
Answer the question before asking your own
Answer what they actually asked, which is usually whether this changes anything for you. One plain line about where you are is enough. Say you're still deciding what you want, or that you're mostly focused on meeting people in person, whichever is true. Keep the tone level. Don't perform being fine, and don't make a show of hurt either.
Then ask one question that tells you about their plans, such as how long they've been on there or what they're hoping will be different this time. Pick something that lets them answer honestly. Skip anything that turns into a loyalty test, like asking whether they're talking to anyone else, unless you've already agreed on exclusivity. One question moves the conversation forward. Three questions turn it into an interview.
Give it a day, then follow up once
Reply within the same part of the day they wrote to you, but not within the first few minutes. An instant reply to a disclosure can read as anxious, and a reply at 2am reads as more than it is. If they answer with real content, keep going and let the topic fade on its own.
If the message goes unanswered, wait about two days before one follow up. Make it light and specific, with a suggested plan or a plain question about whether they still want to talk, so it's easy to answer. Don't mention the dating sites again. If that also goes quiet, stop. Two unanswered messages after a disclosure like this is an answer, and a third only makes you the person who kept chasing.
Why these replies fail
“Oh, so you're not really looking for anything with me then?”
It turns her honest answer into a test she now has to pass, so she ends up defending herself.
“Haha cool. Anyway, what's the best show you've watched lately?”
It skips past the thing she just told you, which reads as either not listening or not caring.
“Honestly I'd delete them all if I were you, that's kind of a red flag.”
It lectures her about choices she only described, which puts you in the position of judging her.
Common mistakes
- Matching their honesty with a long confession about your own history
- Asking whether they're talking to anyone else before you've agreed on anything
- Acting hurt, then going quiet to make a point
- Replying with a joke that skips over the thing they just said
- Sending a second and third message on the same day when they haven't answered
Questions people ask
- Is it a red flag if they say they're still on other dating sites?
- Not on its own. Saying it openly is often a good sign, since it means they aren't hiding it. What matters more is how they behave over the next few weeks. If they make plans, reply consistently, and get clearer about what they want, the mention was just honesty about where they were starting. If they stay vague and avoid timelines, take that as your answer.
- Should I ask them to delete everything before we keep dating?
- Only if you've agreed on exclusivity or you're ready to commit to it yourself. Asking for deletion early tends to turn a relaxed conversation into a negotiation. A better move is to say what you want from the next few weeks, such as one in person date a week, then see whether they meet you there. Their actions will tell you more than a promise would.
- How long should I wait for a reply after they mention it?
- Give it a day or two before any follow up. If they replied to your first message, a few hours is normal and you don't need to respond faster than they do. If you haven't heard anything after two days, send one light message with a concrete suggestion. If that goes unanswered too, stop and move on rather than sending more.
- Do I bring it up again on the next date?
- Usually no, unless they do. Once you've answered the question and they've responded, the topic has done its job. Bringing it up again can make it sound like you're still holding it against them. If they raise it later, answer briefly and honestly, then go back to the rest of the date.
What people say after using WingAI
“I overthink every text. Having three options and picking the one that sounds like me cut that spiral short.”
Sam R.
“I always freeze on the first sentence. This gets me past that blank box so I actually hit send.”
joejoe4567
“I was skeptical at first. Then I tried it on a dry chat and the replies actually sounded like me, not a chatbot.”
Mazoonx
Get replies that sound like you
Screenshot the conversation in WingAI. It reads the vibe and gives you natural replies for this exact situation.
Try for free