He asks if you're talking to others but won't say what he's doing
He wants to know your status but stays silent about his own. Here's how to reply without looking desperate or naive.
When a guy asks if you're seeing other people but gives you nothing about his own situation, he's testing the waters. He might want exclusivity without offering it, or he's unsure but framing it as your problem to solve. Either way, the imbalance matters. A good reply doesn't ignore the question, but it doesn't let him have it both ways either.
Your goal is to stay honest while signaling that you need the same information he's asking for. You're not playing games, but you're also not volunteering to be exclusive with someone who won't be transparent. The reply should feel like a normal follow-up, not an interrogation or a shutdown.
Get replies that sound like you
Screenshot the conversation in WingAI. It reads the vibe and gives you natural replies for this exact situation.
Try for freeThe vagueness is the message itself
A guy who asks about your dating life but stays silent about his own is either hedging his bets or testing how much you'll give away. He might like you but feel uncertain, so he's fishing for a commitment signal from you before he commits. Or he's keeping options open and wants to know if you're doing the same. The vagueness lets him have it both ways. he can claim he just wanted to know, or he can later say he was already exclusive in his head.
Notice that he framed it as a question about you, not a statement about him. That's intentional. He's not saying 'I want to be exclusive' or even 'I'm not talking to anyone else.' He's asking what you're doing. That matters before you answer.
Make it a two-way street without sounding hostile
A good reply does two things at once. First, it acknowledges his question so he doesn't think you dodged him. Second, it makes clear that you need the same information. You're not refusing to answer. You're just not going solo while he sits in the middle.
The tone matters here. You want to sound curious and direct, not suspicious or hurt. This isn't a confrontation. You're just pointing out that you can't give him a real answer until you know what you're both actually doing. A strong reply usually includes a reason why you're asking, even if it's simple. you'd like to know where things stand, or you need to understand what exclusive would mean for both of you.
Send same day, don't wait for him to open up first
Reply while the conversation is still warm. If you wait days, he'll think you're punishing him or avoiding the topic. Send it within a few hours of his message, when it's natural to keep texting.
If he doesn't answer your reply or deflects again, you have your answer. He's not ready to be honest or exclusive, and waiting longer won't change that. After a second non-answer, stop bringing it up. You've asked twice. The next move is his. If he comes back with a real answer later, great. If not, you've already learned what matters. he wasn't willing to be clear with you.
Why these replies fail
“No, I'm only talking to you”
It rewards his one-sided question and shows you'll commit without knowing if he will, which gives him zero reason to be honest about his situation.
“Why do you care? Are you jealous or something?”
It makes you sound defensive and turns the conversation into an argument instead of getting the answer you actually need.
“I mean, I was talking to other people, but I can stop if you want to be exclusive”
You're offering to cut off your options before he's even said what he wants, which puts all the power in his hands.
Common mistakes
- Answering fully without asking what he's doing, which rewards his one-sided question
- Getting defensive or sarcastic, which makes you look threatened instead of thoughtful
- Lying about talking to others when you aren't, hoping he'll commit faster
- Asking him directly what he's doing without first making it clear why the question matters
- Over-explaining or justifying why you were talking to other people
Questions people ask
- Should I just answer his question and hope he volunteers the info later?
- No. If you answer without asking, you've removed his reason to be honest. He got what he wanted. Later, when you ask, it will feel like you're bringing up the topic again instead of having a real conversation about it now. Answer his question, but tie it to asking what he's doing.
- What if he says he's not talking to anyone else and I believe him?
- Then you have your answer and can decide whether you want exclusivity too. But if he gave you that answer without you asking, that's different from him dodging. Trust what he actually says, not the vagueness.
- Is it okay to ask him directly 'Are you seeing other people?'
- Yes, absolutely. Direct is fine. The point is to ask it alongside your own answer, so it's a real exchange instead of an interrogation. Something like 'I'm not, but I'd like to know if you are' or 'I want to know where you stand on this' works.
- What if he never answers even after I ask back?
- That's your answer. He's either not ready for this conversation or he's keeping options open. You can't force clarity. After he dodges twice, stop asking and decide if you're comfortable dating someone who won't be straight with you.
What people say after using WingAI
“I overthink every text. Having three options and picking the one that sounds like me cut that spiral short.”
Sam R.
“I was skeptical at first. Then I tried it on a dry chat and the replies actually sounded like me, not a chatbot.”
Mazoonx
“Used it for a couple hours and set up a date the same night. Not even kidding.”
Nikola2214
Get replies that sound like you
Screenshot the conversation in WingAI. It reads the vibe and gives you natural replies for this exact situation.
Try for free