How to reply when he says he's talking to someone else but wants to hang
He's exploring options but still interested in you. Here's how to respond without playing it cool or overcommitting.
He's being honest that he's in the early dating phase with someone else, but he still wants to see you. This is actually a clear signal. He's not hiding it, which means he's not treating you as a backup he needs to keep secret. He's just managing multiple early connections, which is normal before exclusivity talks.
Your reply needs to show you heard him without pretending this doesn't matter or playing games in response. A good reply sets a boundary or stakes without drama, and it gives him a real choice instead of leaving things vague. Vague is how guys keep multiple people on the line indefinitely.
The move here is to be direct back. You're allowed to have a preference about how this works. You're not obligated to hang out with someone who's actively dating others if that bothers you, and you're also allowed to be cool with it if you're doing the same thing. Either way, say it clearly.
Get replies that sound like you
Screenshot the conversation in WingAI. It reads the vibe and gives you natural replies for this exact situation.
Try for freeHe chose honesty over lying or dodging
A lot of guys in this position just don't mention the other person and let you find out later. He told you upfront. That's not nothing. It means he respects you enough to give you information to make your own choice, even though it was awkward to say.
This doesn't mean he's committed to you. It means he's not running a con. Read it for what it is. He likes you enough to not lie, and he likes someone else too, and that's where things stand. Your job is to decide if you want to hang out with him under those conditions or not.
Set your boundary, not his
A good reply does two things. First, it acknowledges what he said so he knows you actually heard it. Second, it tells him what you're okay with. Not what he should do. What you will do.
You might be fine with going out while he's still exploring options. You might not be. You might want to wait and see if things progress or fade with the other person. You might want to stop hanging out altogether. None of these are wrong. Just pick one and state it. Let him decide if he can work with it. That's how you avoid wasting three months waiting for a guy to choose while he's still unsure.
Send it within 24 hours and give him room to answer
Reply while the conversation is still fresh, not three days later when it seems like you've been sitting with it. Quick reply shows you're not spiraling. It also keeps him from overthinking the silence.
If he doesn't respond after 48 hours, assume his schedule is chaotic or he's lost interest. Don't follow up. If he ghosts after you set a boundary, that's information too. He couldn't meet it. You move on. If he does respond and matches your energy, you've got your answer about what's actually possible here.
Why these replies fail
“lol ok cool, have fun with that”
Sounds mad even if you're not, and it closes the conversation instead of actually deciding anything.
“yeah totally fine with it, let me know what day works!”
You're saying yes to everything without checking in with yourself first, which leads to resentment when he's still texting her between dates with you.
“who is she? how long have you been talking?”
Turns it into an interrogation instead of a choice, and puts his answer in control of your decision.
Common mistakes
- Playing hurt or mad to make him feel bad for mentioning it, which just wastes time.
- Saying yes immediately to prove you're chill, then resenting him later for not choosing you.
- Going silent to punish the honesty, which teaches him never to be transparent again.
- Asking him questions about the other person instead of deciding what you actually want.
- Matching his casualness so hard that you seem like you don't care, which kills his interest.
Questions people ask
- Does him telling me mean he's going to choose me?
- Not necessarily. He told you because you deserve to know where you stand. It's a sign he respects you, not a sign he's picking you. He's still exploring. If he stops talking to the other person later, that's when it means something. Until then, treat this as information, not a promise.
- Should I tell him I'm talking to other people too?
- Only if it's true and only if it changes your answer to hanging out. If you're also in the early dating phase with others, you can mention it to level the playing field. If you're not, don't make it up to match him. Just say yes or no to what you actually want.
- What if I say I want to wait and he disappears?
- That means he couldn't wait, which tells you everything. A guy who likes you and respects your boundary will either agree or disappear, and both outcomes are useful information. One means he's worth your time. The other means he's not.
- How long do I wait before deciding I'm wasting my time?
- If you go out with him and he's still actively dating someone else months later without any movement toward exclusivity, stop waiting. You'll know it feels stalled. Don't ask him why. Just pull back. If he wants things to progress, he'll notice and do something about it.
What people say after using WingAI
“I overthink every text. Having three options and picking the one that sounds like me cut that spiral short.”
Sam R.
“I was skeptical at first. Then I tried it on a dry chat and the replies actually sounded like me, not a chatbot.”
Mazoonx
“She went cold mid-week and I had no idea what to say. The reply I sent felt natural and she picked the chat back up.”
Marcus T.
Get replies that sound like you
Screenshot the conversation in WingAI. It reads the vibe and gives you natural replies for this exact situation.
Try for free